Saturday, December 18, 2021

A Simple, Classic Shortbread Recipe + A Ted Lasso Biscuit Box for Gifting

In October my dear neighbor turned 50. Knowing her love for Ted Lasso, I thought it would be fun to bake her some shortbread and pack it into a pink "biscuit" box. When I couldn't find anything suitable to order, I searched for one I could craft, which led me to an adorable template, which I promptly printed, cut out, taped, and stuffed with a few bars of homemade "biscuits".

As fun as it was to get lost in a little craft project, it was a bit of a pain, too — my flimsy printer paper couldn't quite handle a full sheet of pink ink, and it wasn't quite up for the box-making job either. As I pasted two sheets of paper together, I thought: Maybe I could have boxes made?

A little research led me to a site called Packola, which led to the creation of these Ted Lasso biscuit boxes, which you can order here. Boxes are sold in packs of 10 for $20. This simple shortbread recipe will be included. Shipping is free 🎉🎉🎉🎉

A Simple, Classic Shortbread Recipe

When I set out to make a Ted Lasso "biscuit" recipe for my neighbor, I started with my favorite shortbread recipe: Melissa Clark's Rosemary Shortbread, an astonishingly simple recipe made in the food processor. I knew I would omit the rosemary and honey, and I knew I would sprinkle it, as Ted Lasso does, with some sort of sugar out of the oven.

But I thought about making another change as well: swapping out some of the flour for cornstarch or rice flour, a move that would give the shortbread more of that melt-in-your-mouth texture. I referenced many recipes — Tartine's, Milk Bar's, Bouchon Bakery's, The New York Times — all of which at their core are similar, the makeup being nearly equal parts by weight butter and flour, a smaller amount of sugar, a bit of salt, and sometimes some sort of starch.

What I found through my experiments is that swapping out some of the flour for cornstarch indeed led to a very tender and finely textured cookie. But what I also found, is that I actually prefer the density and richness of a shortbread cookie made without any starch.

In the end, the recipe here is simply Melissa's without the rosemary and honey but with a splash of vanilla, which, I know, for some people is sacrilege. If you are using really good butter, I understand this logic — shortbread should be all about that really good butter and not clouded by other flavorings. But if you are not, I don't see the harm, and I find the addition to be nice. Simply omit it if you are a shortbread purist.

One final note: This recipe does not call for a food processor. Through my experiments, I found myself really liking Tartine's mix-by-hand method. You will need room temperature butter, but if your butter is not very soft — as in mayonnaise soft — you can do what Tartine suggests: melt a small amount of it; then mix the melted butter with the softened butter. It works likes a charm!

I have made this shortbread recipe both ways — food processor and by hand — and I find there to be no difference in the texture of the cookie in the end. And as much as I love using my food processor, it's nice having an alternative method. Find both methods in the recipe here.

Simple Classic Shortbread

PS: In case you missed it: